i don't know why Sidecar has so few reviews, it's a great restaurant. The food is great and the service is attentive. It's a great place to bring parents or have a nice night out. It's also not crazy busy or loud which is great for a date night.

This is an amazing spot! I've come here multiple times for work lunches. The lobster cobb salad is amazing! The lobster is fresh and cooked perfectly. The bacon is caramelized and delicious. The rice pudding dessert was also delicious and creamy. The service is great. My waitress was personable, friendly, and attentive. I'm overall a big fan and will be back soon!

Sidecar is a reliably great place for lunch. I probably come here every two months or so, and it never disappoints. My meal here a couple of days ago was no exception. Had the house special corn and scallop soup and the wagyu bacon cheddar burger. So. Damn. Good. Oh, and the fries are perfect too. Thin and crispy which is how a fry should be. It can get a little loud, but that doesn't bother me that much. Service is consistently good.

It's weird because I've been here maybe 10 times and this time really stood out! Every other time I thought it was okay but think I finally nailed what to get that wasn't on the lunch menu. Poached lobster roll with mayo/lemon/ butter. So delicious! Their tater tots and CHEESECAKE is also a must! Would have to say their cheesecake is the best I've had so far! The whole party of 4 also agreed :) What else to get? Warm lobster Cobb salad. Anyway, needless to say.. I'll be back here this time actually looking forward to it!

A favorite for business type people (lunches are filled with suits). I've now had a variety of different items on their menu and I was pleased with them all. There's great service and the wait staff truly take the time to ensure your needs are met. This visit I had the oven cooked chicken breast (taking a break from steak) and it was as light as I was looking for. We also had the calamari and deviled eggs which were .

I had a five star St Patrick's Day experience here! Went to the parade on 5th Avenue then walked up the block for an Irish feast! On the menu they had corned beef specials and we ordered both the platter special and the sandwich special. Both were mouthwatering delicious and accompanied with cabbage, potatoes and Irish soda bread. We also had the crab cake which was out of this world, as well as the fish and chips and wagyu burger. The burger was ok, expected a bit more in flavor and size considering the price. Fish and chips were excellent. The clam chowder was good, a bit on the salty side. Service was great. Really enjoyed my St Patty's day here!

I took a chance and walked in to this upstairs private restaurant above PJ Clarke's. I'm not a member and didn't have a reservation but they let me dine anyways. I was a party of one so I sat at the small bar area. Great old classic NYC decor. Service is excellent and we're very attentive. I had a filet and is was awesome. Tender, seasoned perfectly, and chased down with a couple of glasses of red wine. They have a higher end menu than downstairs but with some of the favorites. Great NYC restaurant and a must.